No changes: 5 years passed after Russia was condemned for violating right to education of children in Transnistria -
Connect with us


No changes: 5 years passed after Russia was condemned for violating right to education of children in Transnistria

Source:, Valentin Buda

19 January 2018- Five years passed since the deadline when the Russian Federation had to execute the decision of the European Court for Human Rights in the cases of the children studying in Latin-script schools in Moldova’s Transnistrian region, reports TV8. Accordingly, the human rights NGO “Promo-LEX” says that the children in Transnistria still suffer from Russia’s violations.

On 19 October 2012, the Grand Chamber of the ECtHR condemned Russia for violating the right to education (Article 2, Protocol 1 of ECHR) of children in Transnistria, a breakaway region of Moldova where Russia has nearly direct control of. The Court found that Moldova is responsible for the violations, but also decided that Russia has to pay 1020 thousand euros of moral damage and 50 thousand euros of representation costs to the plaintiffs.

The plaintiffs were citizens of Moldova, residents of the Transnistrian region- primarily parents, teachers, pupils-, who in 2004 and 2006 complained about the violation of the right to education, privacy, and non-discrimination. They were forced to accept education systems imposed by the Russia-backed “Pridnestrovian Moldovan Republic” or to leave for Latin script schools instead of the “Moldovan language” (Cyrillic script) ones.

One of the Latin-script schools from Transnistria is the Lyceum “Ștefan cel Mare și Sfânt” from the town of Grigoriopol. Forced to be closed in 2002 by the so-called Transnistrian authorities, the school had to move in the village of Doroțcaia, which is on the territory controlled by the constitutional authorities. There, in Doroțcaia, the pupils could study in Romanian, but then they have to make a daily 20 km trip to and from the school. Promo-LEX estimated that, during the 12 years of study, a pupil travels approximately 43000 kilometers from Grigoriopol to Doroțcaia school, and back. Roughly, a trip from Mozambique to Vladivostok:

Source: Promo-LEX, Salvați Școlile din Transnistria

Until now, 5 promotions of pupils had to go through this trip every day to get to the school.

Currently studying International Relations at the University of Pécs, Hungary. Study focus: Transnistrian conflict settlement, Moldovan statehood, Moldovan democracy. Inquiries at [email protected]

Continue Reading


ECtHR: Russia found guilty of violating rights to property, remedy of 1646 landowners and 3 companies in Transnistria, Moldova

17 July 2018- The European Court of Human Rights found that the Russian Federation is guilty of violating the right to property (Art. 13 of the ECHR) and the right to a remedy (Art.1 of Protocol 1 to the ECHR) of 1646 landowners and 3 companies from Dubăsari district, situated left of Nistru river but under the control of constitutional authorities.

The case concerned complaints by 1,646 individual Moldovan applicants and three companies that
they had not been able to access land in the separatist region of the “Moldovan Transdniestrian
Republic” (“the MRT”) or had suffered other restrictions.
The Court found in particular that there had been no legal basis for the “MRT” to deprive the
applicants of access to their land and there had been a violation of their property rights. Given
Russia’s effective control over “the MRT”, it had to take responsibility for the violations the
applicants had suffered. For its part, Moldova had fulfilled its duty to help the applicants by
negotiating their access to the land and granting them compensation for losses.

The landowners live in five villages on the left bank of the River Dniester and are under Moldovan control. They own land which is on the other side of a road which has been claimed by “Pridnestrovian Moldovan Republic” (“PMR”) as its territory.
They worked the land without hindrance between 1992 and 1998, when “the Transnistrian authorities” set up “border” checkpoints and the applicants had to pay various taxes and fees. In 2004 “PMR” declared that the land in question was its property and demanded rent from the applicants. Since 2006, a special land ownership agreement is concluded every year between Chișinău constitutional authorities and the separatist authorities from Tiraspol to allow the farmers work and rent their lands.

The Moldovan authorities were not found guilty in the case because of their attempts since 2006 to compensate the individual landowners and landowning companies while attempting to claim jurisdiction over the left bank territory- Transnistria.

The Court held that Russia was to pay each individual applicant 1500 euros in respect of nonpecuniary
damage, except for three applicants who withdrew their applications. It awarded 115300 euros to Agro-Tiras S.R.L., 80500 euros to Agro-S.A.V.V.A. S.R.L. in respect of pecuniary damage and 50000 euros under the same head to Posedo-Agro S.R.L., to be paid to its successor, Serghei Popa FP. It also awarded each applicant company EUR 5,000 in respect of nonpecuniary damage.
It also ordered that Russia was to pay the costs and expenses of 20000 euros for all the applicants.

But Russia is known for not having paid nearly anything for the victims of this kind of “Transnistrian cases”.

Continue Reading


ECtHR: Russia guilty of ill-treatment, poor detention conditions of 5 Moldova policemen in Transnistria

17 July 2018- Russia was found guilty by the ECtHR of ill-treatment and poor detention conditions of five Moldova police officers. The five police officers had been detained in 2006 by the authorities of the so-called “Pridnestrovian Moldovan Republic”. (Judgment 50157/06 from 17/07/2018)
The police officers were reportedly forced to confess that they intended to kidnap politicians and other persons from the region while actually conducting an investigation in Tiraspol.

During the detention, officer Mangîr was allegedly beaten up and injected with an unknown substance which made him stay unconscious for 4 days. His internment in Moldova’s MAI hospital after the release had “concussion” as the cause. Officers Pohila, Dațco, Vasiliev were beaten and threatened with the killing of family members, as well with being transferred to cells occupied by common criminals. Officer Condrea was subjected to “Palestinian hanging” for up to 7 hours, being taken unconscious to the cell.

Russia was found to be exercising “effective control” in the region, “by virtue of its continued military, economic and political support” for separatists. Russia will have to pay approximately 93 thousand euros to Mangîr and his fellow policemen for damage and expenses. Accordingly, “Moldova had taken all the measures in its power” to ensure respect for individual applicants’ rights. Thus, it was not found guilty of violating the rights of the applicants.

Continue Reading


4 military columns moved unannounced on Dubăsari-Grigoriopol-Tiraspol road, ignoring peacekeeping observers

Photo of the military column from last week

23 June 2018- Another serious violation was committed in the Security Zone.

In the morning of June 23rd, at 4 o’clock in the morning, at 6.30, 11.15, and 13.15 in the afternoon, four columns of military vehicles were spotted moving unannounced on the Dubăsari-Grigoriopol-Tiraspol road.

According to the press-release of the Moldovan delegation to the Joint Control Commission, approximately 11 TAB and 25 trucks (URAL, ZIL, UAZ) were moving on the road without any symbols of belonging to either the OGRT or the peacekeeping mission, with number plates missing. Moreover, the columns were accompanied by the Transnistrian “special police forces”.

The Moldovan delegation managed to gather military observers from all the peacekeeping parties around 5.30 in the Dubăsari and Grigoriopol districts (close to the Dubăsari bridge and Doroțcaia, Mălăiești villages) to document the incident. At 6.20, the OSCE Mission representatives spotted 4 URAL trucks and a military vehicle unit, observed later in Mălăiești village at 7.15.

When asked to stop, the military vehicles reportedly did not react in any way.

Previously, the Russian representatives claimed that the three military columns that moved towards the Colbasna munition deposit last week had the goal to increase security at the munition deposit in Colbasna in the wake of possible “terrorist acts and provocative actions” during the World Cup.

Contacted by, Moldova’s Reintegration Minister, Cristina Lesnic told that Chișinău asked OSCE to clarify what kind of vehicles were spotted, what they were transporting.

Besides the 441 “peacekeepers”, Russia holds the Operative Group of the Russian Forces in the Transnistrian region of Moldova containing approximately 1200 regular soldiers, mainly recruited among locals. The Group is the new shape of the former 14th Guards Army of the Soviet Union that is illegally stationed in Transnistria after the collapse of SU. The Group and the Peacekeeping Mission are strongly interconnected through the rotation of troops between them, and both contain local Transnistrian men with Russian passports, despite their neutrality claims.

In 2017 and the start of 2018, experts have seen a significant increase in OGRT’s military activity.

On 22 June 2018, the United Nations General Assembly adopted by a simple majority Moldova’s resolution titled “Complete and unconditional withdrawal of foreign military forces from the territory of the Republic of Moldova”. The resolution calls on the UN Member States to urge the Russian Federation to “complete orderly, unconditionally and without further delay the withdrawal of the Russian Operational Group of Russian Forces” (more commonly known as OGRT or OGRV), in accordance to its commitment agreed at the 1999 OSCE Istanbul Summit, but also the UN Charter.

Continue Reading

Latest News

Important4 weeks ago

Weekly Roundup: Kozak is back, EU Council concerned about Moldova, Shor threatens with a belt

The Weekly Roundup is back after a two weeks break. Sorry about that, the world outside the window was more...

Politics4 weeks ago

IRI Survey: 46% of Moldovans would vote for joining the European Union, 36%- Eurasian Union

16 July 2018- The International Republican Institute published a new poll on the social-political opinions of Moldovan people. The poll...

Politics1 month ago

MAE: Romania attaches great importance to Moldova, Georgia, Ukraine’s political association with EU

Romania attaches great importance to speeding up the economic integration and political association of the Republic of Moldova, Georgia and...

Reintegration1 month ago

ECtHR: Russia found guilty of violating rights to property, remedy of 1646 landowners and 3 companies in Transnistria, Moldova

17 July 2018- The European Court of Human Rights found that the Russian Federation is guilty of violating the right...

Reintegration1 month ago

ECtHR: Russia guilty of ill-treatment, poor detention conditions of 5 Moldova policemen in Transnistria

17 July 2018- Russia was found guilty by the ECtHR of ill-treatment and poor detention conditions of five Moldova police...

Economy1 month ago

Getting citizenship for investments: is it good or bad?

Granting citizenship to the people having invested into the Moldovan economy is a form of passively capitalizing on Moldova’s status...

Politics1 month ago

Poll: PSRM- 49%, PPDA – 15%, PDM – 13% and PAS – 11%

Should parliamentary elections be held next Sunday, four parties would pass over the threshold into the legislature. They are PSRM,...